Deck and fence staining in coastal BC: how often and which stain
The short answer
Benjamin Moore’s contractor guidance notes that most homeowners have their decks refinished every two to three years, and recommends a maintenance clean about once a year. Treat that as a starting point: sun, rain and foot traffic decide the real interval. For opacity, lighter stains show more grain, solid stains hide more, and the condition of the wood should guide the choice.
How often a deck or fence needs restaining
There is no fixed date on the calendar. Benjamin Moore’s contractor add-on guide says most homeowners have their decks refinished every two to three years. Its deck prep guide for contractors recommends a maintenance clean approximately once a year, and says some environmental conditions call for cleaning more often.
A deck takes more wear than a fence. The boards are flat, so rain sits on them and the sun hits them square, and people walk on them every day. A fence stands upright and sheds water. So a fence and the deck next to it will not always need stain in the same year. The only reliable answer comes from looking at the wood.
Signs your deck needs restaining
Look at the deck in daylight, after it has been dry for a while. Signs it is due:
- Faded colour. The stain looks washed out, especially on the boards that get the most sun.
- Grey wood. Bare, weathered wood turns grey. Benjamin Moore’s guide treats grayed-out wood as its own condition, with its own prep before stain goes on.
- Peeling or flaking. The old coating is lifting off the boards, usually where people walk most.
- Mould, mildew or water stains. These are among the conditions Benjamin Moore’s prep products are made to deal with.
Benjamin Moore also gives a simple water test in its deck staining guide. Sprinkle water on the wood. If it beads, the wood is too wet or, on new wood, has a glossy mill glaze. If it soaks in quickly, the wood is ready to accept stain once it has been cleaned.
Translucent, semi-transparent, semi-solid or solid
Exterior wood stains come in a range of opacities. Benjamin Moore’s Woodluxe line, for example, runs from translucent through semi-transparent and semi-solid to solid, plus an ultra-flat solid.
Benjamin Moore’s fence staining guide puts the trade-off simply: translucent stain shows the grain and texture of the wood, solid stain hides imperfections, and semi-transparent or semi-solid stains sit in the middle. The choice depends on what you like and the condition of the wood.
In plain terms:
- Translucent (transparent). The most natural look. The grain and texture show through, so any flaws in the wood show too.
- Semi-transparent. A middle ground: more colour than translucent, with the grain still showing.
- Semi-solid. Also a middle ground, closer to solid. More colour and coverage, less grain.
- Solid. Hides the most, including imperfections in older or patched wood.
Coats differ too. Benjamin Moore’s deck guide says translucent, semi-transparent and semi-solid stains need one coat, while solid stains may need one or two for even coverage.
One thing to weigh before going opaque: Benjamin Moore’s contractor guide says its stain remover should not be diluted on surfaces with multiple coats, or with solid or semi-solid stain. Heavier coatings take more work to strip if you ever want to go back to a lighter look.
Prep: dealing with old, peeling coatings
Most of what makes a stain job look even and last happens before the stain is opened. Benjamin Moore’s deck guide sets out prep by condition:
- Peeling or flaking old stain. Remove the loose stain by power washing, wire brushing or sanding, use a stain remover on what remains, rinse, then apply a brightener and neutralizer. Sand until smooth.
- Weathered, grey wood. Clean with a wood restorer and a stiff brush to take off loose, dead fibres, rinse, then brighten and neutralize.
- New or treated wood. Use a brightener and neutralizer to break the mill glaze, scrub and rinse.
After washing, the guide says to let the wood dry for at least 48 hours and sand with 80-grit sandpaper. You cannot stain over loose, peeling coating and expect the new coat to hold.
The before and after photos on our deck and fence staining page show a deck whose old red coating had worn through to bare wood, prepped and restained an even deep red.
Weather: temperature, sun and rain
On the coast, the main job is finding a dry window. Benjamin Moore’s deck guide says to pick rain-free days with a dry forecast for at least 36 hours before you stain, on wood that has had 48 hours to dry after prep.
For fences, Benjamin Moore advises staining on a low-humidity day between 4 and 32 degrees C, and stopping if rain starts until it eases and the surface is dry. Its general temperature guide adds that the surface should be at least 5 degrees above the dew point, and that each product’s own range is on its label or technical data sheet.
Sun matters as much as rain. Both guides say to avoid staining in direct sunlight, because stain that dries too fast leaves lap marks. Working in shade, a few full boards at a time and with the grain, keeps the colour even.
Fences: long runs, both sides, posts
A fence is a different job from a deck. There is less foot traffic, but a lot more surface.
- Long runs. Benjamin Moore’s fence guide says to work from the top down, brush horizontal boards horizontally and vertical boards vertically, and not to stop in the middle of a board. On a long fence, that is what keeps the colour from looking patchy.
- Both sides. Decide up front whether the neighbour’s side is part of the job, and sort out access before the work starts.
- Posts and rails. Posts and the rails between panels are easy to miss. Make sure the quote says whether they are included.
- Prep. The fence guide says to remove hardware and loose nails or screws, replace cracked boards, clean the fence, and sand rough edges with 120 to 150-grit sandpaper.
- Surroundings. Tarps over walkways and plants, and tape and plastic where the fence meets the house.
A fence is often done at the same time as the deck or an exterior repaint, so the whole property gets finished in one visit.
What moves the price
We do not publish price ranges, because every deck and fence is different. What moves the price:
- The size of the deck, or the length and height of the fence
- Whether one side or both sides of the fence are stained
- How much old coating has to come off
- The condition of the wood, including boards that need replacing
- The opacity and number of coats
- Stairs, railings and other detail work
Ivy League Painting stains decks and fences in Tsawwassen, Ladner, the rest of Delta and Richmond. Every job starts with a free, on-site, written quote, and we reply within one business day. We carry $5 million liability insurance and offer a 3-year, 100% satisfaction guarantee. Jack and Henry have been painting in Delta for 10 years. Get a free quote.
Frequently asked questions
Should I stain or paint my deck?
Benjamin Moore says stain is the way to go when you want to keep the natural grain and colour of the wood, while paint gives a more uniform solid colour and hides imperfections. Ivy League Painting’s deck and fence work is staining. Bring up opacity at your free on-site quote.
How long before I can walk on a freshly stained deck?
Benjamin Moore’s deck guide says a deck takes about 48 hours to fully dry and to wait at least two days before allowing foot traffic. Check the product label too, since dry and return-to-service times vary by product.
What about pets?
Keep pets off the deck for the same drying period as people: at least two days, per Benjamin Moore’s deck guide, or longer if the label says so. Paws on wet stain leave marks on the deck and stain on everything else.
Can you stain cedar fences?
Yes. Ivy League Painting stains cedar fences, including long street-side runs. Benjamin Moore’s guidance sorts prep by the wood’s condition (new, weathered, or with old peeling stain), and the same approach applies to cedar.
Can you stain over old, peeling stain?
Not directly. Benjamin Moore’s deck guide says old peeling or flaking stain has to be removed first, then the wood rinsed, brightened and sanded. New stain over a failing coat fails with it.
How often should I clean my deck between stain jobs?
Benjamin Moore’s contractor guide recommends a maintenance clean approximately once a year, and more often in some conditions. A clean deck also makes it easier to spot fading, greying or peeling early.
Sources
- How to stain a deck (Benjamin Moore Canada)
- Save time with proper deck stain preparation (Benjamin Moore Canada, contractors)
- Top exterior project add-ons for clients (Benjamin Moore Canada, contractors)
- How to stain a fence (Benjamin Moore Canada)
- Temperature guide for exterior painting (Benjamin Moore Canada)
- How to choose the right exterior wood stain (Benjamin Moore)